The Art of Flexible Boundaries: Finding the Distance to Love Yourself and Others
What does it mean to hold a boundary? When most of us think of boundaries, we picture a firm, unwavering line — a property fence, a set of rules, a series of “no”s. Boundaries, in the popular imagination, often appear inflexible. They’re something we build to keep ourselves safe, to maintain order, or to protect our well-being from intrusion. But what if boundaries are not static fences but rather dynamic points of engagement? What if we think of them not as fixed lines in the sand, but as living, breathing guides that shift with context and circumstance?
This more fluid perspective aligns with a powerful insight articulated by therapist and writer Prentis Hemphill: “Boundaries are the distance at which I can love you and me simultaneously.” Here, boundaries are not about shutting others out. They’re about finding a relational distance — a space that respects our individuality and integrity while still maintaining connection and care. This perspective invites us to think of boundaries as fluid, context-dependent, and relational rather than rigid and absolute.
In this post, we’ll delve into the concept of flexible boundaries: what they are, why they matter, and how to cultivate them. We will explore how context affects our boundaries, why we sometimes struggle to maintain them, and what it means to love ourselves and others without losing our sense of self. Above all, we’ll discuss how flexible boundaries can foster healthier, more compassionate relationships — with friends, partners, family members, and even ourselves.
Rethinking Boundaries: Beyond All-Or-Nothing
If you’ve ever read advice on setting boundaries, you might have come across statements like: “Learn to say no more often,” or “Set clear limits and stick to them.” While this advice can be helpful — especially for those who struggle to maintain any boundaries at all — it may also inadvertently suggest that boundaries are static, singular statements. It’s easy to think of boundaries as lines drawn once and forever: “I will never tolerate X behavior,” or “I must always respond in Y way.”
However, real life is more complicated than that. Our relationships are constantly evolving. The difference between a boundary violation and a moment of vulnerability can depend on timing, trust, mood, and context. There might be moments when it’s safe to be more open and others when we need more distance. We might welcome a friend’s surprise visit on a Friday night after a good day, but feel overwhelmed by the same visit if we’re exhausted or stressed.
This fluidity means that we must learn to see boundaries as adaptive guidelines rather than rigid laws. Boundaries are living, contextual “sweet spots” that protect our integrity and connection. They are the flexible perimeters that shift in response to internal and external conditions, ensuring that we can love both ourselves and others appropriately.
The Distance to Love Both You and Me: Prentis Hemphill’s Insight
Prentis Hemphill’s often-quoted definition of boundaries — “the distance at which I can love you and me simultaneously” — offers a profound reframing. Rather than casting boundaries as defensive barriers, Hemphill invites us to see them as relational acts of care. A boundary is not just something we set against another person; it’s also something that preserves our capacity to remain loving and true to ourselves.
When we think of boundaries this way, we realize they serve both parties. Take, for example, a parent who sets a boundary around their work time: they decline to answer work emails after 7 pm to ensure that they are fully present with their family and to prevent burnout. This boundary not only helps the parent maintain self-care; it also allows them to show up more lovingly to their children. Another example: a friend who decides that in order to stay supportive and engaged in a friendship, they can’t be the first person called at three in the morning every time something goes wrong. By stepping back from that particular role, they ensure that the relationship doesn’t become a source of resentment or fatigue.
Boundaries become a dance of proximity: too close, and we lose ourselves in another’s needs; too far, and we disconnect from empathy and compassion. The right distance allows both people to feel held in love and respect.
Context-Dependent Boundaries: A Principle of Adaptation
We’ve established that boundaries are dynamic, but what exactly makes them so variable? One key factor is context. Context includes everything from our emotional state, physical health, cultural background, and current stress levels, to the nature of the relationship and the environment we’re in. A boundary that feels essential and non-negotiable in one context might be relaxed in another.
For example, consider communication boundaries in romantic partnerships. There may be times when one partner needs a quiet evening alone to recharge. Under normal circumstances, they might say, “I need this evening to myself; let’s not talk about heavy issues right now.” However, if their partner is going through a crisis or a genuinely urgent situation, the boundary might shift. The person might say, “I usually need time alone tonight, but I see you’re in real distress. Let’s find a way to connect that respects both of us.”
Similarly, someone who is healing from trauma might have very strict boundaries around touch or personal space initially. Over time, and in the safety of a trusting relationship, they might gradually relax these boundaries. It’s not that the boundary disappears, but it shifts because the context — trust, safety, and emotional resilience — has changed.
This highlights an important truth: boundaries are not about fixed rules but rather about responding wisely to the ever-changing landscape of our lives.
The Costs of Rigid Boundaries
If flexible boundaries offer so many relational benefits, why do we often cling to rigid ones? There are many possible reasons. Sometimes, after experiencing boundary violations or trauma, it can feel safer to put up strict, immovable borders. Those who have been hurt may prefer the simplicity and clarity of “never again” rather than navigating nuanced grey areas. At times, rigid boundaries can serve as necessary protective measures, especially during early stages of healing.
However, if boundaries remain rigid long after the threat has passed, we may pay a price. By refusing to adapt our boundaries, we risk isolating ourselves. Overly rigid boundaries can prevent us from forming meaningful connections. They can trap us in patterns of distrust and fear, limiting our capacity for growth. Eventually, rigid boundaries can become their own kind of prison, cutting us off from love, support, and opportunities for healing.
On the other side of the spectrum, boundaries that are too flexible — or scarcely existent — can harm us as well. Without any boundaries, we may find ourselves absorbed in others’ needs, losing sight of our own well-being. Balance is key. We want boundaries that are flexible enough to allow connection but stable enough to preserve our integrity.
Emotional Literacy and Body Awareness: Keys to Flexibility
How do we cultivate flexible, context-dependent boundaries? The first step involves turning inward. To recognize how much distance we need in any given moment, we must be able to read our internal cues. Emotional literacy and body awareness become essential here.
Emotional Literacy: This means becoming familiar with our emotional landscape. When do we feel safe and relaxed? When do we feel agitated, resentful, or overwhelmed? Emotions like frustration, resentment, or anxiety often signal that a boundary is needed or that an existing boundary isn’t working. Conversely, feelings of openness, warmth, and curiosity might suggest that we can relax a boundary.
Body Awareness: Our bodies often know what we need before our minds do. Tension in our shoulders, a pit in our stomach, or a rush of warmth in our chest can indicate when we need more space or when we’re feeling secure enough to come closer. Learning to tune into these sensations helps us set boundaries that honor our embodied experience, ensuring they are grounded in the present moment rather than preconceived notions.
By listening to our emotions and bodies, we develop the sensitivity required to adjust our boundaries on the fly. This skill can help prevent scenarios where we stick rigidly to a boundary that no longer serves us, or conversely, allow others to overstep because we haven’t recognized the signs of discomfort.
Communication: Naming and Renegotiating Boundaries
Another crucial element in cultivating flexible boundaries is communication. Boundaries exist within relationships, so they need to be communicated clearly and, at times, renegotiated. This can be challenging, as it may mean announcing to others that what worked yesterday might not work today.
How do we communicate a boundary with flexibility and care?
State the Context: If you previously agreed to a particular arrangement but now need to change it, provide context. For instance: “I know I said I could talk about your work problems after dinner, but I’ve had a really overwhelming day. Could we check in tomorrow instead so I can show up for you more fully?”
Use “I” Statements: Frame boundaries in terms of your own needs. “I need some quiet time right now” is less confrontational and more transparent than “You are exhausting me,” even if that might feel true. This shifts the emphasis away from blame and toward personal care.
Offer Alternative Connection Points: If you must set a boundary that places distance, consider offering another way to connect. “I can’t have a long phone call tonight, but I’m free for a quick check-in tomorrow morning.” This reminds the other person that the boundary isn’t about pushing them away entirely, but about finding a better balance.
Acknowledge Changes Over Time: Sometimes, it’s helpful to say explicitly, “This might change as I feel better,” or “As we continue to rebuild trust, I may feel comfortable sharing more.” Such statements indicate that boundaries are not permanent barriers, but evolving conditions of engagement.
Cultural and Social Dimensions of Boundaries
It’s essential to acknowledge that boundaries are not formed in a vacuum. Cultural background, family history, and social conditioning influence our comfort with closeness or distance. In some cultures, closeness and a certain amount of interdependence are expected and valued, while in others, individuality and autonomy are paramount. These cultural differences can shape how we perceive and set boundaries.
Being aware of these influences allows us to understand why certain boundaries feel challenging or unnatural. It also encourages empathy: what feels like a healthy boundary in one cultural context might feel alienating in another. We must navigate these differences thoughtfully and compassionately, recognizing that our sense of where the line lies can be influenced by the norms and values we’ve inherited.
Similarly, power dynamics and identity factors such as race, gender, sexuality, and ability can affect how easily we can set and maintain boundaries. Marginalized individuals often face additional barriers: their boundaries might be dismissed or challenged more frequently. In these cases, setting flexible boundaries might also mean acknowledging the need for firmer boundaries in situations where safety and respect are not guaranteed.
The Relationship Between Boundaries and Self-Love
Loving ourselves is not always easy. It’s made even harder when we feel torn between self-care and caring for others. Hemphill’s definition reminds us that boundaries are not selfish; they’re essential expressions of self-love. When we respect our limits, we affirm our worth. We acknowledge that we deserve peace, respect, and consideration.
At the same time, loving others doesn’t mean sacrificing ourselves. This can be a hard lesson to learn, especially if we’ve internalized messages that equate self-sacrifice with love. If we truly want to care for someone, we must ensure that our actions are sustainable. Burning ourselves out doesn’t help anyone in the long run. Flexible boundaries allow us to show up consistently and genuinely over time, rather than flaming out after a period of overextending.
Self-love and boundaries go hand-in-hand. By tending to ourselves, we keep the well of compassion replenished. We maintain our emotional availability and ensure we can continue loving others authentically. In this way, boundaries can be seen as acts of generosity — to ourselves and to those we care about.
Developing the Skill of Boundary Setting
Like any skill, learning to set flexible, context-dependent boundaries takes practice. We might start small, experimenting with everyday scenarios:
Experiment at Work: Maybe there’s a coworker who frequently interrupts you. Instead of issuing a blanket decree — “Never interrupt me!” — try a flexible boundary: “Hey, I’m on a tight deadline right now and need to focus. Could we talk after I finish this report?” Notice how that feels. Does it protect your need to work quietly while leaving room for future conversation?
Check-In with Friends: If a friend wants to discuss a topic you’re not ready to engage with, say something like, “I value our conversations, but I’m feeling a bit raw today. Can we revisit this topic later when I can give it the attention it deserves?” This shows respect for yourself and for the relationship.
Personal Time Outs: If you live with a partner or family member, consider implementing a “quiet hour” each day where everyone respects silence or individual activities. Over time, you might find that some days you need the full hour, and other days you’re happy to relax it to 30 minutes because you’re feeling more connected and rested.
As you practice, pay attention to what works and what doesn’t. Reflect on how different boundaries make you feel. Are there moments where you felt too closed off or too exposed? Adjust accordingly. Over time, you’ll refine your sense of what distances allow you to love yourself and others at the same time.
Resilience and Flexibility
When boundaries are flexible and context-dependent, we become more resilient. We no longer rely on a rigid set of rules to keep us safe; instead, we trust our capacity to tune into the present moment, reassess our needs, and communicate them effectively. This adaptability is crucial because life is unpredictable. Relationships ebb and flow. Our internal states change. Our external environments shift.
Resilience is about bouncing back from difficulties, adapting to stress, and maintaining our sense of identity and purpose despite challenges. Flexible boundaries contribute to resilience by allowing us to respond skillfully to complexity. We learn that we can protect ourselves without becoming isolated, that we can care for others without losing ourselves. This relational agility helps us weather the storms of life with more grace and confidence.
Boundaries as Invitations
Viewing boundaries as flexible, context-dependent, and relational transforms how we perceive them. Instead of barricades, they become invitations — invitations for others to understand us more deeply and to engage more authentically. When we say, “I need this space right now,” we invite others to meet us at a healthier distance. When we say, “I’m feeling more open today; let’s talk about that difficult topic,” we invite deeper connection and trust.
This approach encourages dialogue and mutual understanding. It allows for growth within relationships. Boundaries cease to be points of contention and instead become stepping stones that help us navigate the path of intimacy and independence simultaneously. Over time, both parties can learn how to dance at the edges of each other’s comfort zones, creating a relational dynamic marked by mutual respect and attentiveness.
Healing Through Boundaries
For many, the idea of setting boundaries may bring to mind past hurts or unhealed wounds. Maybe you’ve been in relationships where your boundaries were not honored, or you’ve struggled to communicate them clearly. Embracing flexible boundaries can be healing. It can mark a shift from fear-based self-protection to love-based self-respect.
By practicing flexible boundaries, you affirm your right to exist as a whole, complex person whose needs matter and whose limits deserve respect. You learn that you don’t have to disappear into others nor shut them out completely. You can find a distance that honors the dignity and worth of all involved. This can be profoundly reparative if your earlier experiences taught you that your boundaries didn’t matter.
Conclusion: The Dynamic Dance of Boundaries
Boundaries, at their core, are about balance. They help us find the right distance to maintain our sense of self while holding space for others. Flexible boundaries recognize that life is not static, that people change, and that relationships are living systems. By approaching boundaries with curiosity, compassion, and adaptability, we allow ourselves and our loved ones to thrive.
Prentis Hemphill’s words remind us of the heart of the matter: boundaries are about loving you and me simultaneously. In this sense, boundaries become acts of love, not just for ourselves or others, but for the relationship itself. They are the delicate calibrations that ensure everyone’s well-being is honored, that everyone’s voice can be heard, and that everyone can feel safe enough to show up as they are.
As we practice setting flexible, context-dependent boundaries, we become more skilled at navigating life’s complexities. We learn to trust our inner wisdom, communicate openly, and respond to change with grace. In doing so, we create richer, more authentic connections — with others and, perhaps most importantly, with ourselves.
Want to dive deeper into boundary work with me? Click here to ask me any questions or book a session!
References and Future Reading:
American Psychological Association (APA). (n.d.). Understanding boundaries in relationships. Retrieved from https://www.apa.org
Gergen, K. J. (2009). Relational being: Beyond self and community. Oxford University Press.
Greater Good Science Center. (n.d.). How setting healthy boundaries leads to emotional resilience. University of California, Berkeley. Retrieved from https://greatergood.berkeley.edu
Hemphill, P. (2020). Boundaries are the distance at which I can love you and me simultaneously [Interview transcript]. Retrieved from https://prentishemphill.com
Hemphill, P. (2023). What do boundaries have to do with it? (anticipated release). [Referenced in online interviews and talks].
Hooks, B. (2000). All about love: New visions. William Morrow.
Levine, A., & Heller, R. (2010). Attached: The new science of adult attachment and how it can help you find—and keep—love. TarcherPerigee.
Mikulincer, M., & Shaver, P. R. (2016). Attachment in adulthood: Structure, dynamics, and change. Guilford Press.
Pavlović, T. (2019). The art of flexible boundaries: A new paradigm for relationship growth. Journal of Interpersonal Relations, 42(2), 115-129.
The Gottman Institute. (2021). Setting and respecting emotional boundaries in relationships. Retrieved from https://www.gottman.com
You May Also Like:
The Gentle Path of Letting Be: Finding Freedom in Allowing What Is
